It is fairly easy to understand why France, Germany,
China and Russia oppose removing Saddam Hussein
by force; all of those countries are doing profitable
business with Saddam and all of them would like to
see American power diminished.
But Pope John Paul II is another matter. His opposition
to military action is understandable in theory, but
troubling in practice.
John Paul has sent his emissary, Cardinal Pio Loghi, to
tell President Bush that attacking Iraq would be "unjust"
and "immoral."
That's like sending Sister Mary Theresa to tell Eminem
to stop cursing.
The President is firmly convinced that Saddam is an
evil man with murder on his mind.
Short of Jesus appearing in the Oval Office with an
opposing point of view, Mr. Bush is not going to change
his opinion.
The Catholic Church embraces the tradition of "just
war." That is that any use of force must be
accompanied by clear and convincing evidence that
only force will solve a situation that is both threatening
and immoral.
And since there is the possibility that U.N. weapons
inspectors might be able to restrain Saddam, the Pope
believes there are still options to war.
The problem with this argument is faith, pardon the pun.
The Pope is putting his faith in a system of inspections
that very well might fail.
If that happens and even a portion of Saddam's
unaccounted for 8,500 liters of anthrax are used
against people, a worldwide catastrophe would ensue.
The Pope does not answer questions so it is impossible
to know what he thinks about that possibility.
We also don't know how John Paul squares keeping
the Saddam in power considering his murderous past.
It's one thing for the Vatican to condemn Saddam's
gassing of the Kurds, mass murder and rape in Kuwait,
and funding of suicide bombing expeditions, it is quite
another to prevent those things.
So what are America's 65 million Catholics supposed to
do?
Theologically, the Pope is on firm ground.
Humanistically, he is one of the many Saddam
enablers. If the nations of the world would unite
against evil things like Saddam, and the insanity of
countries like North Korea, deadly situations would be
solved and the world would be a better, safer place.
But the world will not unite against evil and the Pope
does not call for that practical unification. Instead, he
calls for peace.
Does he really believe Saddam and Kim Jong Il are
listening?
The Catholic Church teaches "tranquillitas ordinis," the
peace of order which is supposed to be imposed by
legal and political means.
But as the world has seen, Osama Bin Laden, Adolph
Hitler and, yes, Saddam Hussein has not been real
bullish on "the peace of order."
Instead, they have embraced the practice of "violent
chaos."
As a loyal Catholic, I am glad the Pope is praying for
America and for peace. I pray his prayers will work a
miracle and Saddam will be removed from power
without bloodshed.
But if that miracle is not forthcoming, this Catholic does
not have faith that Saddam will not use his outlawed
anthrax somewhere down the line.
And so to prevent the mass death that took place in
Europe and Asia while another Pope was praying 60
years ago, I support the moral quest of removing a
dangerous killer from power.